I'm interested in finding information on whale communications; intelligence
functions; different aspects of whale intelligence; thought processes;
sensory processes. The sperm whale has the largest brain on earth, I
think. What do they do with it all? How good are our efforts to
Susannah Smith, Ph.D.
That would be a topic for a graduate seminar, or actually a new
interdisciplinary Department of Cetacean Cognition. I think we have to
start with a realistic appraisal of our own vantage point, in comparison to
the evolutionary history of the largest and largest-brained cetaceans.
We're far more recently evolved as self-conscious, culture-building
mammals, and our brains are much smaller. Actually, recent measurements by
Dr. Rich Osborne indicate that orca brains are slightly larger than sperm
whale brains, but both are around five times the size of human brains.
What do they do with it all? I'm quite sure nobody knows. Anything we know
varies tremendously by species. Most cetacean communication seems to lack
great diversity or complexity, but maybe we're not looking for the right
elements within the calls. Or maybe all that needs to be said can be said
in a few calls. It may be helpful to note that cetaceans don't make things,
or have any material culture. So they probably don't have a need to take
things apart and name the parts, or to name things much at all. With social
and ecological stability gained over millions of years, there may not be
much new to talk about. Until humans disrupted the marine ecosystem just
recently, cetaceans had pretty well managed to live long and prosper within
the parameters of a finite planet, with a minimum of hostility. Maybe
that's an answer to what they do with it all. The difficulty may lie in our
inability to remove the lens of our values and biases to consider what such
a history of conscious intelligence on such a scale may bring. What would
peace on Earth be like?
Though I'm sure there are people trying to look into the cetacean mind, I'm
not aware of much new theory that's based on empirical studies rather than
sheer speculation. The most exciting new theory that I know of was a 2001
paper called Culture in Whales and Dolphins, which you can find at:
My main interest is in orca communication and social systems. The
proposition I'm working on is that orcas, and by implication several other
species, are aware of themselves as both individuals and as members of
their cultures, as we are. I've borrowed a paradigm from a subdiscipline of
sociology called symbolic interactionism. You can find my attempt to put it
all together at:
http://www.orcanetwork.org/nathist/scifield.html#interactionism. Some of
the other papers in that section may be of interest to you as well.
Keep in touch if you'd like. I'd love to hear what you find.
This archive was generated by hypermail 2b30 : Tue May 27 2003 - 08:08:41 EDT