Abstract: Natural Markings (fwd)

From: Pita Admininstrator (pita@whale.wheelock.edu)
Date: Fri Oct 12 2001 - 12:15:59 EDT

  • Next message: Pita Admininstrator: "Gray whale rib cage (fwd)"

    Subject: Abstract: Natural Markings

    The following paper has recently been published which may be of interest to
    MARMAM subscribers.

    Peter T. Stevick, Per J. Palsbøll, Tim D. Smith, Mark V. Bravington and
    Philip S. Hammond. 2001 Errors in identification using natural markings:
    rates, sources and effects on capture-recapture estimates of abundance.
    Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences 58:1861-1870.


    The results of a double-marking experiment using natural markings and
    microsatellite genetic markers to identify humpback whales (Megaptera
    novaeangliae) confirm that natural markings are a reliable means of
    identifying individuals on a large scale. Of 1410 instances of double tagging
    there were 414 re-sightings. No false positive and 14 false negative errors
    were identified.The rate of error increased with decreasing photographic
    quality; no errors were observed among photographs of the highest quality
    rating while an error rate of 0.125 was identified in sightings for which
    only part of the area used for identification was visible. There was also a
    weaker relationship between error rate and the distinctiveness of markings,
    which may result from non-independence in coding for image quality and
    distinctiveness. A correction is developed for the Petersen two-sample
    abundance estimator to account for false negative errors in identification
    and a parametric bootstrap procedure for estimation of variance is also
    developed. In application to abundance estimates from the North Atlantic, the
    correction reduces the bias in estimates made using poorer quality
    photographs to a negligible level while maintaining comparable precision.

    A limited number of reprints are available. Please contact Peter Stevick, PO
    Box 93, Rockport, ME 04856, USA <PeterStevick@aol.com>.

    Peter Stevick

    This archive was generated by hypermail 2b30 : Fri Oct 12 2001 - 12:16:03 EDT